05.28.08
Review: “The Forbidden Kingdom”

Jet Li and Jackie Chan in “The Forbidden Kingdom.”
Seen one martial arts fantasy film, seen them all. Or, at least, that is what this film would have you believe. The first time paring of martial arts specialists, Jet Li and Jackie Chan, would seem like a rather obvious success. Monotony and structural weakness say otherwise, “The Forbidden Kingdom” does nothing if not disappoint. Throwing every ingredient you have seen before into one huge leaky cauldron, and making use of the sharply timed skills of two uncompromised legends makes no difference when it is very clear from the yawn-inspiring opening scenes just how stale these ingredients are. The film is a formulaic yet satirical look at the extreme seriousness most martial art films have, and its blatant attempts at humour are obvious and cringe worthy. There is no attempt at creating something fresh or new, and if there was, it could not have been concealed any better. A lower than average take on the overplayed juvenile cross-cultural-cross-time adventure idea, “The Forbidden Kingdom” should be taken literally, stay away at all costs.
It borrows heavily from other martial arts films, cinematic homages perhaps, which may be part of its intended charm, but charm it does not. Jason Tripitikas (Michael Angarano), a typical martial-arts loving kid from Boston, visits a Chinatown pawn store owned by an ancient Chinese man (Jackie Chan, aged with prosthetics). A rather greasy throwback to the 50’s and his gang force Jason to assist them in robbing the store, but everything goes wrong. Jason conveniently ends up with a magical staff in his hands, and just like that he is teleported to ancient China with one mission and one mission only, return the staff to its rightful owner, “The Monkey King” (a particularly furry Jet Li), as frozen as an immortal stone statue can be. Jason teams up with a drunken vagabond named Lu Yan (Jackie Chan), an all-white silent monk (Jet Li) and an orphan determined to get revenge against those responsible for her parents’ deaths who calls herself ”Golden Sparrow” (Liu Yifei). Together they prepare to ensure that the prophesy of the “Monkey King” is fulfilled and the immortal Jade Warlord (Collin Chou) ceases to gain power of the staff which would mean the triumph of Evil over Good, and we wouldn’t want that… It either sounds too familiar or too wearisome, either way it does not manage to maintain any sense of captivation throughout its long-winded running time.
All very conventional in premise, the execution is surprisingly uninteresting and often inconsequential as well, and the fight scenes leave much to be desired. Practicality aside, the uninventive choreography does not even hint at the level of greatness seen in films such as “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.” But it would be unfair to compare this Rob Minkoff (“Stuart Little,” “The Haunted Mansion”) directed film to Ang Lee’s epic masterpiece. One thing they do share is the logically unexplainable gravity defying sequences, which were awe-inspiring the first few times they were used in film, but now come across as inferior imitations.
The majority of the film was shot in China, on location or in studios, and the visuals are, for the most part, crisp and striking, along with the costumes and an overall production design that is note-worthily fantastic – but the way in which the story unfolds detracts from the visuals, and the undeniable charisma of Jackie Chan and Jet Li is completely wasted. Jackie Chan gives the most rewarding performance of the film, however, and often makes you forget that you are bearing witness to utter drivel. Michael Angarano is completely uninteresting and dull, and gives white martial arts obsessed teenage nerds everywhere a bad name.
With an overload of clichés and generic stereotypes, the film wants to be nothing more than an almost-satisfying film that is bound to impress juvenile viewers, or ones that have not experienced the hypnotism of previous films in which Jet Li and Jackie Chan are able to display their magic to its fullest extent – and their collaboration is below par. Control and order, key to any martial arts battle, would have resulted in a cohesively constructed film, and not just a culmination of wasted performances and less than sufficient distractions.
Fatac Rating: **
The Forbidden Kingdom. Directed by Rob Minkoff. Written by John Fusco. Cinematography by Peter Pau. Music by David Buckley. Starring: Jackie Chan, Jet Li, Michael Angarano, Bingbing Li, Yifei Liu and Collin Chou Running Time: 133 minutes. Age Restriction: PG 13. USA 2008. Rating out of five stars.
Matthew Lucas said,
May 29, 2008 at 6:04 am
Very nicely done indeed, Nicky! I had friends who saw this and enjoyed it, but I never got around to it. I may still yet, but I’ll approach with reservations.
Bad reviews suit you…you should do this more often. ;-)
Nick Plowman said,
May 29, 2008 at 10:10 am
You have no idea how much I dislike this film, I was completely bored, like I was checking my email on my phone within the first few minutes. But then I stopped, and tried to give it my undivided attention, and what did I get in return? Nothing, absolutely nothing.
If you don’t get the chance to see it for whatever reason, count yourself lucky.
I will post reviews of films that are bad, just that when I started writing reviews, it was Oscar season and I skipped many bad films in order to make time for the good ones, hence all the reviews for good films. I try to write a review for every film I see that is from 2007/2008, but writing a review for this film was so hard.
But hey, there will be plenty films that I love – those are the ones I enjoy writing about, if they can touch me in whatever way, you know? This one did nothing for me, sadly.
J.D. said,
May 29, 2008 at 6:02 pm
Christ, dude, STOP BEING AWESOME.
I feel drunk.
Nick Plowman said,
May 29, 2008 at 6:05 pm
Drunk is good – even Jackie Chan makes a good drunk.
Craig Kennedy said,
May 29, 2008 at 7:44 pm
(in super tiny voice) I liked it!
Nick Plowman said,
May 29, 2008 at 7:47 pm
When you said you liked it, I thought that I would to, but I didn’t.
Most people that I know that have seen it, enjoyed it.
As far as recent kung-fu/martial arts movies go, “Kung Fu Panda” is one of the best. IMO.
Craig Kennedy said,
May 29, 2008 at 8:17 pm
That’s cool that you liked KP considering you were a little skeptical.
Nick Plowman said,
May 29, 2008 at 8:21 pm
The trailer for “Panda” highlights most of the bad stuff, and the real good stuff happens in between those bad parts. Visually, “Panda” is amazing, animated China looks better than real China. I think.
Craig Kennedy said,
May 29, 2008 at 10:38 pm
I generally like Pixar stuff better, but I was trying to keep an open mind about Panda. It’s not at the top of my list or anything, but I plan to check it out.
Seriously though, you didn’t enjoy Kingdom even in a “dumb turn your brain off fun” kind of way?
I must be a bigger retard than I thought.
Nick Plowman said,
May 30, 2008 at 6:09 am
Yeah, so do I, I mean I cannot freaking wait to see Wall*E man. “Panda” will no doubt be forgotten when “Wall*E” opens, which sucks.
Nah, unfortunately I did not, but it’s cool that you liked it, I respect that, the film is hard to HATE because it has a certain quality that many films don’t have, and it has its heart in the right place, but I was totally bored. Maybe I am more of a retard, who knows.
Kung Fu Fighting Kotsengkuba said,
August 15, 2008 at 4:09 pm
The Forbidden Kingdom has every element a good Chinese Martial Arts movie should have especially the female warrior whose hair shrinks and stretches at will. Classic! ;-) The link goes to a full single file streaming movie from YouKu.com